Survivors of sexual abuse who file a civil claim worry that the defense will dig into their private lives. California law limits that tactic in a specific way. Understanding the rule helps a survivor judge what to expect before a case begins.
California limits what the defense can say about a survivor’s past
Under California Evidence Code section 1106, a defendant in a civil sexual assault, sexual battery, or sexual harassment case cannot offer opinion, reputation, or specific-instance evidence about the plaintiff’s sexual conduct to argue consent or a lack of injury. The bar on injury arguments does not apply when the claimed injury is loss of consortium.
The limit also applies when the defense tries to use that history to challenge the survivor’s credibility on consent or injury. The section does not keep out evidence offered to challenge credibility on subjects other than consent or injury. The legislature amended the section in 2024, with the changes taking effect on January 1, 2025.
Some evidence falls outside the protection
Evidence of the survivor’s sexual conduct with the alleged perpetrator falls outside the bar. Subdivision (b) sets that exception. Another subdivision of the same section covers cases that involve a minor and an adult.
A survivor who wants to understand how these limits apply to a specific claim would ask a Santa Clara County sexual abuse lawyer, who represents survivors only, how the section fits the facts. That focus keeps the claim centered on what happened to the survivor.
Procedure shapes how sensitive subjects reach the court
The section also provides that if a survivor presents evidence about sexual conduct through their own testimony or another witness, the defendant may cross-examine on that evidence. The defendant may also offer relevant evidence, but only to rebut it.
A survivor can rely on the following protections during a civil case:
- The defense cannot use sexual history to argue that the survivor consented.
- The defense cannot use that history to argue that no injury occurred.
- The defense cannot use it to attack the survivor’s credibility on consent or injury.
Injury remains the focus of a survivor’s claim
The rule blocks efforts to argue that no harm occurred, so a claim for PTSD damages can rest on records of the harm itself. Treatment records and a survivor’s own testimony carry that proof.
Therapists, physicians, and counselors who treat a survivor can document the emotional and physical effects of abuse. That documentation records the nature of the harm and the care it required.
Other safeguards work alongside the evidence rule
Procedural protections beyond the evidence rule also exist for protecting abuse victims from unnecessary exposure during litigation. The right protection depends on the facts of the case.
Each protection addresses a different risk, such as public disclosure of a name, exposure of medical records, or release of a home address. The court decides each request on the facts of that case.
Claims against schools and institutions raise added issues
When abuse occurred at a school or another institution, a survivor would ask a school sexual abuse lawyer what the organization knew, how it supervised staff, and how it responded to reports. Those facts bear on whether the institution shares responsibility.
Institutional claims involve records, personnel files, and witness accounts that a survivor can’t gather alone. The evidence rule still applies to those cases, so the defense faces the same limits on questions about sexual history.
Adult and childhood cases involve different facts
An adult survivor of assault may also have a related criminal matter, and a survivor would ask a sexual assault victim lawyer how the civil claim fits alongside it. The civil claim runs on its own timeline.
Adult survivors bring claims for assault, battery, or harassment, and the evidence rule applies to each of those claim types. Cases that involve a child need added care because the statute includes a separate provision for minors.
Families dealing with childhood abuse would ask a molestation lawyer how that provision applies to the survivor’s claim. The provision keeps evidence of a minor’s conduct with an adult defendant from proving consent or a lack of injury.
Survivors decide how to move forward
A survivor can move at their own pace when deciding whether to file. The limits on sexual-history evidence are one reason the civil process can be less invasive than survivors fear.
Kelly Van Aken and Mikayla Kellogg are the founding partners of Kellogg & Van Aken LLP, our firm, and both attended UC Davis School of Law. Both are members of the Consumer Attorneys of California.
Survivors deserve to bring a claim without having their private lives put on display. Anyone considering a civil case should schedule a confidential discussion with a Santa Clara County sexual abuse lawyer about how the evidence rules apply to their situation.
I contacted KVA with an inquiry about a landlord-tenant dispute. I worked with both Kelly Van Aken and Mikayla Gow Kellogg, who are true professionals: they listened closely to my case, made …
Thanks for the amazing work, Kelly! You guys are so awesome! I was just talking to my dad about how killer you’ve been with my case. I’m so happy I decided to go with you.
We truly appreciate your efforts, professionalism, and compassion for the situation we faced. Kelly was really on top of things and communicated diligently on every aspect …
I was about to sign a lease, but then decided to contact [KVA] with some questions I had first. I’m so glad I did! Mikayla Gow Kellogg thoroughly looked over the lease and not only was …
Thank you for all your help! It was a long journey, and I definitely learned a lot about our judicial system. I will always remember how desperately I waited for our first Skype conversation in …